What characteristic is associated with the early phase of Gothic Revival architecture?

The early phase of Gothic Revival architecture is characterized by a rich aesthetic that often prioritized visual splendor over strict adherence to scholarly historical accuracy. This approach embraced ornate details, highly decorative elements, and a general sense of grandeur that was intended to evoke the emotional and spiritual essence of the original Gothic cathedrals. The focus on creating visually striking buildings led to an emphasis on elaborate designs, which sometimes overshadowed a rigorous or scholarly interpretation of historical styles.

In this context, the choice that states "rich but comparatively unscholarly" effectively captures the essence of the early Gothic Revival, as many architects and designers during this period were more focused on the emotive power and beauty of their designs rather than an academic study of Gothic forms. This is indicative of a broader trend within the movement that valued the emotional and sensory experiences associated with architecture over purely intellectual engagement with historical precedents.